← Library

〜のに(逆接(ぎゃくせつ))Even though: 〜のに

N4Concession and contrastLesson 13 · 'If', 'even if' and 'although'

Plain form + のに means 'even though' with surprise or disappointment; nouns and な-adjectives take なのに in the present.

この店(みせ)のパンは安(やす)いのに、おいしいです。 The bread at this shop is cheap, and yet it's good.日曜日(にちようび)なのに、父(ちち)は会社(かいしゃ)に行(い)きました。 Even though it was Sunday, my father went to work.

のに links two facts: the first leads you to expect one thing, and something else happens instead. The speaker is let down, surprised or reproachful: 薬(くすり)を飲(の)んだのに、まだ痛(いた)い. A plain 'but', けど, is more neutral; のに adds the speaker's feelings.

Uses:

1
A fact that goes against what you'd expect. The first fact leads you to expect one thing, and something else happens: the speaker is disappointed, surprised, or blames someone. Both facts are true.
  • 約束(やくそく)したのに、彼(かれ)は来(き)ませんでした。 He promised, and yet he didn't come.
  • この店(みせ)は有名(ゆうめい)なのに、お客(きゃく)さんが少(すく)ないです。 Even though this restaurant is famous, it has few customers.
  • 手紙(てがみ)を出(だ)したのに、まだ返事(へんじ)が来(き)ません。 I sent the letter, and yet there's still no reply.
2
At the end of a sentence: a reproach or a wish. のに can close the sentence, leaving the second part unsaid. After 〜ばよかった it is a reproach or a regret, 'you could have…'; after 〜といい it is a wish about something that isn't the case, 'if only…'.
  • もっと早(はや)く言(い)ってくれればよかったのに。 You could have told me sooner.
  • 私(わたし)も日本語(にほんご)が上手(じょうず)に話(はな)せるといいのに。 If only I could speak Japanese well too.
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.
Later on: At N3, you'll learn 〜くせに, an 'even though' that criticizes the person doing the action.

How it attaches

  • Verbplain formのに行(い)ったのに
  • い-adjective〜いのに寒(さむ)いのに
  • な-adjective〜なのに静(しず)かなのに
  • Nounnounなのに雨(あめ)なのに
  • な-adjective, noun (past)〜だったのに休(やす)みだったのに

Pay attention to

  • な-adjectives and nouns: なのに. As before ので and んです, the present needs な; the mistake comes from the だ of だけど:×雨(あめ)だのに ○雨(あめ)なのに In the past you keep だった: 雨(あめ)だったのに.
  • In the second part: a fact, not a request. What follows のに is a fact, not a request, an invitation or a decision by the speaker: for those, use けど:×寒(さむ)いのに、散歩(さんぽ)に行(い)きましょう ○寒(さむ)いけど、散歩(さんぽ)に行(い)きましょう
  • ても or のに. 〜ても also works for something merely possible: 明日(あした)忙(いそが)しくても、行(い)きます, 'even if I'm busy tomorrow, I'll go'. のに needs a fact that is already true, and adds disappointment or surprise: 忙(いそが)しいのに、来(き)てくれました, 'he was busy, and yet he came'.
  • The other のに: 'for'. With 使(つか)う, 便利(べんり), 役(やく)に立(た)つ, かかる or 必要(ひつよう) after it, のに says what something is for (〜のに): このペンは漢字(かんじ)を書(か)くのに便利(べんり)です. When what follows goes against what you'd expect, it is the 'even though' of this card: 新(あたら)しいペンを買(か)ったのに、使(つか)っていません.

Minimal pairs

  • 雨(あめ)なのに、出(で)かけた。

    Even though it was raining, he went out.

    雨(あめ)なので、出(で)かけなかった。

    It was raining, so he didn't go out.

    The rain is the same in both sentences. With のに, going out is unexpected despite the rain; with ので, the rain explains why he didn't go out.

Don't confuse with

  • Because: 〜のでN4

    ので gives the reason ('so'), のに means 'even though': 勉強(べんきょう)しなかったので、落(お)ちた is the expected consequence; 勉強(べんきょう)したのに、落(お)ちた is the unexpected one, with the disappointment.

  • But: 〜けど and 〜がN5

    Both set two facts against each other, but けど (or the more formal が) is a neutral 'but' and のに adds disappointment or surprise: 高(たか)いけど、買(か)いました is a plain remark; 高(たか)いのに、買(か)いました says the purchase was unexpected.

Report a mistake