← Library

〜ずにはおかない・〜ずにはすまない・〜を余儀(よぎ)なくされるNo way round it: 〜ずにはおかない, 〜ずにはすまない, 〜を余儀なくされる

N1Obligation, permission and prohibitionLesson 15 · Formal Japanese: going by the rules, no way round it, and the written word

ずにはおかない describes an inevitable effect; ずにはすまない, an unavoidable duty; を余儀(よぎ)なくされる, being forced by events.

最後(さいご)の最後(さいご)に決(き)まったゴールは、観客(かんきゃく)を沸(わ)かせずにはおかなかった。 A goal right at the very end was always going to send the crowd wild.新(あたら)しい町(まち)に引(ひ)っ越(こ)してきたのだから、近所(きんじょ)の人(ひと)にあいさつに行(い)かずにはすまない。 We've just moved to a new town, so there's no getting out of going around to say hello to the neighbors.大雨(おおあめ)で線路(せんろ)が壊(こわ)れ、町(まち)の人(ひと)たちは三日間(みっかかん)、バスでの通勤(つうきん)を余儀(よぎ)なくされた。 Heavy rain damaged the rail line, and for three days people in the town had no choice but to go to work by bus.

All three are about something that can't be avoided, and all three belong to formal Japanese. ないではおかない and ないではすまない mean the same as the forms with ず.

Uses:

1
Bound to stir people: 〜ずにはおかない. Something, such as a smell, a sight or a decision, is bound to stir a feeling or a reaction in people. The subject is a thing, or someone other than the speaker. With 〜せる or 〜させる, the verb names what people are made to feel or do. Said by the speaker about their own plans, the same form expresses a firm resolve, 'I won't rest until…', and then the subject is the speaker.
  • 焼きたてのパンのにおいは、通る人の足を止めさせずにはおかない。 The smell of freshly baked bread is bound to stop passersby in their tracks.
  • 料金を急に上げれば、客の不満を招かずにはおかないだろう。 Raising prices suddenly is bound to upset customers.
  • この店を、必ず町で一番の店にせずにはおかない。 I'm going to make this the best shop in town, whatever it takes.
2
Something you can't get out of: 〜ずにはすまない. Given what has happened, or what people expect, there is no way around doing something: apologizing, explaining, paying, asking someone. The matter won't be settled until it is done. It is awkward to use for something you feel you must do for personal reasons. With a passive verb, it describes something unwelcome that is bound to happen to you.
  • 約束の日までに家具を届けられなかったのだから、お客さんに事情を説明せずにはすまない。 We couldn't deliver the furniture by the agreed date, so we'll have to explain the situation to the customer.
  • 親の家を売るなら、兄にも相談しないではすまない。 If we're selling our parents' house, we can't avoid talking it over with my brother too.
3
Forced by circumstances: 〜を余儀なくされる. Circumstances leave no other option, and someone has to take a step they didn't choose: moving, stopping, putting something off. The noun before を names that step, as with 中止(ちゅうし) or 変更(へんこう). With を余儀(よぎ)なくさせる, the cause does the forcing. Usually the subject of される is a person and the subject of させる a thing.
  • 道路を広げる工事のため、角の小さな花屋は移転を余儀なくされた。 Because of the road-widening work, the little florist on the corner was forced to move.
  • 観光客の急な増加が、町にごみの集め方の見直しを余儀なくさせた。 A sudden rise in tourist numbers forced the town to rethink the way it collects garbage.
Two expressions built on で済(す)む (N3) express that something lighter won't be enough. では済(す)まない means 'it won't end with just…': 注意(ちゅうい)だけでは済(す)まない, 'a warning won't be the end of it'. て済(す)むことではない means '… won't settle it': お金(かね)を返(かえ)して済(す)むことではない, 'paying the money back won't settle it'.
Close to these are ざるを得(え)ない (N2), 'have no choice but to', and ずにはいられない (N2), 'can't help doing'.
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.

How it attaches

  • Verbない form: 〜ないずにはおかない, ずにはすまない知らせずにはすまない
  • Verb in the 'make someone do' form〜(さ)せないずにはおかない驚かせずにはおかない
  • するする → せずにはおかない, せずにはすまない相談せずにはすまない
  • Verb, with ないない formではおかない, ではすまない言わないではすまない
  • Noun; the subject is forced〜を余儀(よぎ)なくされる変更を余儀なくされる
  • Noun; the subject does the forcing〜を余儀(よぎ)なくさせる延期を余儀なくさせる

Pay attention to

  • With する: せずには. For other verbs ず is built on the ない form (言(い)わない, 言(い)わず); する is the exception, and building it on しない gives the wrong form:×説明(せつめい)しずにはすまない ○説明(せつめい)せずにはすまない
  • 余儀(よぎ)なくされる or 余儀(よぎ)なくさせる. With される, the subject is the one being forced; with させる, the subject is the cause. With the snow as the subject, only させる works:×大雪(おおゆき)が試合(しあい)の中止(ちゅうし)を余儀(よぎ)なくされた ○大雪(おおゆき)が試合(しあい)の中止(ちゅうし)を余儀(よぎ)なくさせた
  • In everyday Japanese: ないわけにはいかない. ずにはすまない is formal and not very common; to say 'I'll have to…' in everyday Japanese, ないわけにはいかない does the job: 今日中(きょうじゅう)に返事(へんじ)しないわけにはいかない, 'I'll have to reply today'.

Don't confuse with

  • Have no choice but to: 〜ざるを得ない, 〜よりほかないN2

    ざるを得(え)ない describes something the speaker does unwillingly, with no other option: 最終(さいしゅう)のバスが出(で)てしまって、タクシーで帰(かえ)らざるを得(え)なかった. ずにはおかない describes an effect that is bound to come: この結果(けっか)は、町(まち)の人(ひと)たちを喜(よろこ)ばせずにはおかない.

  • Can't help feeling; can't afford to keep on: 〜てならない, 〜ないではいられない, 〜てはいられないN2

    ずにはいられない describes what the speaker can't stop themselves doing: 大(おお)きな花火(はなび)が上(あ)がると、声(こえ)を上(あ)げずにはいられない. ずにはおかない describes what something is bound to make people do: 大(おお)きな花火(はなび)は、子供(こども)たちに声(こえ)を上(あ)げさせずにはおかない.

  • Deeply felt: 〜てやまない, 〜に堪えない, 〜を禁じ得ないN1

    驚(おどろ)きを禁(きん)じ得(え)ない, after a noun, describes a feeling the speaker can't hold back. 人(ひと)を驚(おどろ)かせずにはおかない, after a verb, describes what something is bound to do to people.

Report a mistake