← Library

〜てならない・〜ないではいられない・〜てはいられないCan't help feeling; can't afford to keep on: 〜てならない, 〜ないではいられない, 〜てはいられない

N2Perception and sensationsLesson 14 · Bound to be, the best thing to do, as if, can't help feeling

Use て + ならない for feelings you can't shake, ない + ではいられない for urges to act, and て + はいられない when you can't afford to go on.

来週(らいしゅう)の受験(じゅけん)のことを考(かんが)えると、不安(ふあん)でならない。 When I think about next week's entrance exam, I can't help feeling anxious.部屋(へや)が汚(よご)れているのを見(み)ると、掃除(そうじ)せずにはいられない。 When I see a dirty room, I can't help cleaning it.仕事(しごと)がたくさん残(のこ)っている。ゆっくり休(やす)んではいられない。 There's still lots of work left. I can't afford to take it easy.

てならない describes a feeling or a sensation that comes by itself and is too strong to hold back. ないではいられない is about an action the speaker can't stop themselves doing; ずにはいられない means the same, with the ず of ずに. てはいられない is about what the situation won't allow: you can't afford to go on doing something.

Uses:

1
A feeling that comes by itself. A feeling, a sensation or a thought that comes by itself and won't go: a worry, a regret, a memory, the heat. It goes with words for feelings and for what the body feels, and with verbs such as 気(き)がする and 思(おも)い出(だ)される; it is often an unpleasant feeling. It describes what the speaker feels; for someone else, add ようだ or らしい. It is close to てしかたがない.
  • あの時、友達にひどいことを言ってしまったような気がしてならない。 I can't help feeling I said something awful to my friend that time.
  • 毎年この季節になると、亡くなった祖父のことが思い出されてならない。 Every year around this time, I can't help remembering my late grandfather.
  • 兄は、飼っていた犬が死んで、悲しくてならないようだ。 Since his dog died, my brother seems terribly sad.
2
An action you can't resist. The speaker can't stop themselves doing something, however hard they try. ずにはいられない means the same. For someone else, add そうだ, ようだ or らしい.
  • 知らない言葉を聞くと、意味を調べないではいられない。 When I hear a word I don't know, I can't help looking it up.
  • その本の最後のページを読んで、作者に手紙を書かずにはいられなかった。 When I'd read the last page of that book, I couldn't help writing to the author.
  • 姉は新しい服を買うと、誰かに見せずにはいられないようだ。 Whenever my sister buys new clothes, she seems unable to resist showing them to someone.
3
Can't afford to keep on. The situation won't let the speaker go on doing something, or stay as they are. With ばかり, てばかりはいられない says you can't just keep doing one thing.
  • 次の試合まであと三日だ。負けたことをいつまでも悲しんではいられない。 The next match is only three days away. We can't afford to keep feeling sad about losing.
  • 雨がやむのを待ってばかりはいられない。傘を買って出かけよう。 We can't just keep waiting for the rain to stop. Let's buy an umbrella and go.
The last two share いられない, 'can't stay': with ないで in front, you can't stay without doing something; with て, you can't stay doing it.
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.
Later on: In Lesson 15, you'll use 〜ざるを得(え)ない for something you do unwillingly because there's no other choice.

How it attaches

  • Verb (feeling)て formならない気がしてならない
  • い-adjective〜いくてならない悔しくてならない
  • な-adjective〜でならない不思議でならない
  • Verb (action)ない formではいられない聞かないではいられない
  • Verb (action, with ず)ない form: 〜ないずにはいられない (する → せずに)書かずにはいられない
  • Verb (can't afford to)て formはいられない待ってはいられない
  • Verb, with ばかりて formばかりはいられない休んでばかりはいられない
  • な-adjective, noun (can't afford to)〜ではいられない冷静ではいられない

Pay attention to

  • With する: せずに. ず takes the place of ない, which is where the mistake comes from: the ない form of する is しない, but before ず, する becomes せ:×しずにはいられない ○せずにはいられない
  • An action: ないではいられない. English 'can't help' covers both feelings and actions, but てならない goes only with feelings, sensations and things that come to mind by themselves; for something you do, use ないではいられない:×文句(もんく)を言(い)ってならない ○文句(もんく)を言(い)わないではいられない

Minimal pairs

  • その手紙を最後まで読まないではいられなかった。

    I couldn't help reading that letter to the end.

    その手紙を最後まで読んではいられなかった。

    I couldn't afford to read that letter to the end.

    With ないではいられない the speaker couldn't stop reading; with てはいられない the situation didn't allow it, for example because there was no time.

Don't confuse with

  • Written prohibitions and duties: 〜てはならない, 〜ねばならないN2

    One は changes everything, and the meanings are opposite. 泣(な)いてはならない is a rule: you mustn't cry. 泣(な)けてならない, without は and with 泣(な)ける ('be moved to tears'), is a feeling: I can't hold back the tears.

  • Unbearably, can't help it: 〜てしかたがない・〜てたまらないN3

    Both describe a feeling too strong to hold back: 眠(ねむ)くてしかたがない. てならない belongs mainly to written Japanese: 一分(いっぷん)の差(さ)で電車(でんしゃ)に乗(の)り遅(おく)れて、悔(くや)しくてならない. With a verb, though, it has to express a feeling, not something the body does: のどが渇(かわ)く works with てしかたがない, but not with てならない.

  • If things go on like this: 〜ては, 〜ていては, 〜ようではN2

    毎日(まいにち)遊(あそ)んでいては、合格(ごうかく)できない is a condition with a bad result: if you keep playing every day, you won't pass. もう遊(あそ)んではいられない looks at now: the situation won't let you go on playing.

Report a mistake