← Library

〜ざるを得(え)ない・〜よりほかないHave no choice but to: 〜ざるを得ない, 〜よりほかない

N2Obligation, permission and prohibitionLesson 15 · Have no choice but, nothing more than, formal written Japanese

Say you have no other choice with the ない form minus ない + ざるを得(え)ない, or the dictionary form + よりほかない.

家賃(やちん)が上(あ)がったので、引(ひ)っ越(こ)さざるを得(え)ない。 The rent has gone up, so I have no choice but to move.最終(さいしゅう)のバスが出(で)てしまったので、駅(えき)まで歩(ある)くよりほかない。 The last bus has already left, so the only thing to do is walk to the station.

ざる is an old negative that takes the place of ない, and 得(え)ない means 'cannot', as in 〜得(え)ない: literally, 'cannot not do it'. It describes something done unwillingly, because the circumstances leave no other option: the weather, money, an order.

Uses:

1
Doing what the situation forces on you. The circumstances leave one option, and the speaker takes it against their wishes. The one who has to act is usually the speaker, and often goes unsaid. The verb is something people choose to do, such as 中止(ちゅうし)する or 引(ひ)っ越(こ)す; a verb nobody controls, such as 分(わ)かる or 疲(つか)れる, or a potential form, doesn't work.
  • 駅前の駐車場がなくなったので、車をやめて自転車で会社に通わざるを得なくなった。 The parking lot by the station has closed, so I've had no choice but to give up driving and bike to work.
  • 医者に言われたので、毎晩のビールは一本にせざるを得ない。 My doctor has told me to, so I have no choice but to limit myself to one beer a night.
2
Admitting what you can't deny. With verbs such as 言(い)う, 認(みと)める and 思(おも)う, what you're forced into is a judgment: the facts leave no other conclusion, 'I have to say', 'I must admit'. The judgment can be a criticism or praise.
  • 弟の作るカレーは、私のよりおいしいと認めざるを得ない。 I have to admit that the curry my brother makes is better than mine.
  • 三回続けて同じ所で間違えた。やり方に問題があると思わざるを得ない。 I've gone wrong at the same point three times in a row. I have to conclude that my method is the problem.
3
Saying it's the only way left: 〜よりほかない. It means the same as しかない: of all the options, this is the one left. ほかない on its own, よりほかはない and よりしかたがない mean the same. Like しかない, it can also be a choice you're glad to make.
  • 新しい部屋が見つかるまで、友達の家に泊まるよりほかない。 Until I find a new apartment, all I can do is stay at a friend's.
  • この本は図書館にないので、自分で買うほかない。 The library doesn't have this book, so my only option is to buy it myself.
ざるを得(え)ない belongs to written Japanese; in conversation, なきゃ does a similar job. Two N3 forms come close: しかない and 〜ないわけにはいかない.
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.
Later on: You'll see the same ざる before a noun, as in 知(し)られざる名作(めいさく), 'an unknown masterpiece', in this lesson.

How it attaches

  • Verbない form: 〜ないざるを得(え)ない行かざるを得ない
  • するする → せざるを得(え)ない中止せざるを得ない
  • くる来(く)る → 来(こ)ざるを得(え)ない来ざるを得ない
  • Verb, with よりほかないdictionary form(より)ほかない待つよりほかない

Pay attention to

  • する: せざるを得(え)ない. For other verbs ざる takes the place of ない in the ない form (行(い)かない, 行(い)かざる); する is the exception, and building the form on しない gives the wrong result:×参加(さんか)しざるを得(え)ない ○参加(さんか)せざるを得(え)ない
  • ない drops. ざる is already negative, so ない goes; keeping it comes from 〜ないわけにはいかない, where ない stays:×行(い)かないざるを得(え)ない ○行(い)かざるを得(え)ない
  • A choice you're happy with: しかない. ざるを得(え)ない shows that the speaker would rather not, so for something you're glad to do, use しかない or よりほかない: この映画(えいが)、すごく面白(おもしろ)そうだから、週末(しゅうまつ)に見(み)に行(い)くしかないね, 'this movie looks great, so I just have to see it this weekend'.
  • A promise: なければならない. ざるを得(え)ない is only for a situation that leaves no choice; for something you have to do because you promised, use なければならない:×引(ひ)っ越(こ)しを手伝(てつだ)うと約束(やくそく)したので、土曜日(どようび)は行(い)かざるを得(え)ない ○引(ひ)っ越(こ)しを手伝(てつだ)うと約束(やくそく)したので、土曜日(どようび)は行(い)かなければならない

Minimal pairs

  • 客が減ったので、喫茶店を閉めるしかない。

    Customer numbers have fallen, so our only option is to close the café.

    客が減ったので、喫茶店を閉めざるを得ない。

    Customer numbers have fallen, so I have no choice but to close the café.

    Both say closing is the only option left. ざるを得(え)ない also shows that the owner would rather stay open, and belongs to writing; しかない works in conversation, and can also be a choice made gladly.

Don't confuse with

  • No other choice: 〜しかないN3

    しかない is everyday Japanese: 雨(あめ)だから、今日(きょう)は家(いえ)で練習(れんしゅう)するしかない. ざるを得(え)ない says the same in writing, and adds that the speaker would rather not: 熱(ねつ)が下(さ)がらず、試験(しけん)を休(やす)まざるを得(え)なかった.

  • Can't very well: 〜わけにはいかないN3

    行(い)かないわけにはいかない works when there's no choice, and also for a duty: a promise, a favor received. 行(い)かざるを得(え)ない is only for a situation that leaves no choice: 会社(かいしゃ)の車(くるま)が壊(こわ)れたので、自分(じぶん)の車(くるま)で行(い)かざるを得(え)なかった.

  • Can't help feeling; can't afford to keep on: 〜てならない, 〜ないではいられない, 〜てはいられないN2

    ずにはいられない describes something you can't stop yourself doing: あの番組(ばんぐみ)を見(み)ると、笑(わら)わずにはいられない. ざるを得(え)ない describes something you do unwillingly, because the situation leaves no choice: 部長(ぶちょう)の冗談(じょうだん)はつまらないが、笑(わら)わざるを得(え)ない.

  • Possible, impossible, unable to: 〜得る/〜得ない, 〜かねるN2

    In あり得(え)ない, 得(え)ない follows the ます stem, and the sentence says something can't happen. In ざるを得(え)ない it follows ざる, an old 'not', and the two negatives together mean 'have to': 行(い)かざるを得(え)ない.

Report a mistake