← Library

〜得(う)る/〜得(え)ない・〜かねるPossible, impossible, unable to: 〜得る/〜得ない, 〜かねる

N2Possibility, ability and necessityLesson 9 · Possible, if only, no way, if things go on like this

ます stem + 得(う)る/得(え)ない says whether something is possible; use かねる for a polite 'I can't'.

一言(ひとこと)が、人(ひと)を大(おお)きく変(か)え得(う)る。 A single word can change a person a great deal.申(もう)し訳(わけ)ございませんが、その質問(しつもん)にはお答(こた)えしかねます。 I'm afraid I'm unable to answer that question.

得(う)る on its own is a verb meaning 'to get'; after the ます stem it means 'can'. This 'can' expresses a possibility, not a person's ability: whether something may happen or be true. It belongs mostly to writing, though it is also heard in formal speech.

Uses:

1
Something can happen: 〜得る. Something may happen or be true, even if it hasn't happened yet. With verbs nobody controls, such as 起(お)こる and ある, the potential doesn't work, but 得(う)る does: 起(お)こり得(う)る, あり得(う)る.
  • この計画には、まだ問題が起こり得る点がいくつかある。 There are still a few points in this plan where problems could arise.
  • この方法なら、二つの問題を同時に解決し得る。 With this method, both problems could be solved at once.
2
Something can't happen: 〜得ない. With 得(え)ない the possibility is ruled out: the thing can't happen, or can't be true. あり得(え)ない means 'impossible, unthinkable'.
  • 一度も行ったことがない店から請求が来るなんて、あり得ない。 A bill from a shop I've never even been to? That's impossible.
  • この写真の光は、今の科学では説明し得ないものだ。 Today's science can't explain the light in this photo.
3
Declining politely: 〜かねます. It turns down a request, or disagrees, politely: the speaker can't do it in their situation or position. It is typical of formal speech and writing, in conversations between staff and customers or in business letters, for example.
  • 申し訳ございませんが、お部屋の変更はいたしかねます。 I'm very sorry, but we're unable to change your room.
  • そのお値段では、お売りしかねます。 I'm afraid we can't sell it at that price.
4
Holding back: 〜かねる. かねる also describes something a person can't bring themselves to do, even though they would like to: deciding, saying no, asking. 決(き)めかねる is 'can't make up one's mind'.
  • せっかく誘ってもらったので、断りかねている。 They were kind enough to invite me, so I can't bring myself to say no.
  • 先生は忙しそうだったので、質問したかったが、声をかけかねていた。 The teacher looked busy, so although I wanted to ask a question, I held back from approaching her.
In the dictionary form, 得(う)る is read うる or える, and both are correct; うる is the more common. The negative, the past and the ます form always use え: 得(え)ない, 得(え)た, 得(え)ます.
かねる works differently. It isn't about lacking the ability: the speaker can't do something in their situation or position and says so politely, or can't bring themselves to do it.
The ます stem + っこない means 'there's no way…':
  • こんな難(むずか)しい問題(もんだい)、子供(こども)に分(わ)かりっこないよ。 There's no way a child could solve a problem this hard.
Two forms from N3 come close: 〜ようがない and 〜わけがない.
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.
Later on:

How it attaches

  • Verbます stem得(う)る起こり得る
  • Verb (negative)ます stem得(え)ない起こり得ない
  • Noun + する〜し得(う)る解決し得る
  • あるあり得(う)る/得(え)ないあり得ない
  • Verb, with かねるます stemかねる決めかねる

Pay attention to

  • かねます is already a no. English 'I can't' has a 'not' in it, but かねる says no on its own, and with ない it becomes a different form with another meaning:×ご案内(あんない)しかねません ○ご案内(あんない)しかねます
  • Before かねる: the ます stem, not the potential. かねる already contains the 'can't', so a potential before it would say 'can' twice:×受(う)け取(と)れかねます ○受(う)け取(と)りかねます Two verbs are exceptions: 分(わ)かる (分(わ)かりかねます) and できる after a する noun (参加(さんか)できかねます).
  • A skill: the potential. 得(う)る expresses a possibility, not what a person is able to do, so for a skill the potential is used:×兄(あに)は二(に)キロ泳(およ)ぎ得(う)る ○兄(あに)は二(に)キロ泳(およ)げる As a rule it isn't used either for something the situation lets a person do.

Minimal pairs

  • 荷物がいつ届くかは、分かりかねます。

    I'm afraid I can't say when the package will arrive.

    荷物がいつ届くかは、分かりません。

    I don't know when the package will arrive.

    Both mean 'I don't know'. 分(わ)かりかねます says it politely and formally, as staff do with a customer; 分(わ)かりません is a simple answer.

Don't confuse with

  • There's no way: 〜わけがないN3

    Both rule something out. あり得(え)ない says the possibility isn't there at all; わけがない says the speaker is sure, because of something they know, and the reason can come first with から: 鍵(かぎ)をかけたから、開(あ)いているわけがない.

  • There's no way to: 〜ようがない, 〜ようもないN3

    直(なお)しようがない says the means are missing: no tool, no spare part. あり得(え)ない says the thing itself can't happen or be true.

Report a mistake