← Library

〜なり〜なり・〜であれEither… or…; whatever it is: 〜なり〜なり, 〜であれ

N1Listing, examples and choiceLesson 4 · Whatever it is, it all depends, undeterred; and set pairs

〜なり〜なり suggests options to choose from. After a noun, 〜であれ means the same holds, whatever it is.

葉(は)が黄色(きいろ)くなったら、水(みず)を減(へ)らすなり、日(ひ)の当(あ)たる場所(ばしょ)に移(うつ)すなりしてください。 If the leaves turn yellow, water it less or move it somewhere sunnier.どんな小(ちい)さな会社(かいしゃ)であれ、税金(ぜいきん)の書類(しょるい)は毎年(まいとし)出(だ)さなければならない。 Any company, however small, has to file its tax papers every year.

なり〜なり gives two examples of what someone could do and leaves the choice open; something else would do just as well. What follows is a request, a suggestion, or what the speaker wants to do. This isn't the なり of 〜なり, 'as soon as', from Lesson 1: here なり comes twice and gives options. であれ follows a noun or a な-adjective and belongs to writing. As a pair it covers both cases; on its own it means 'even if it is', or, after a question word such as 誰(だれ), 'whoever it is'.

Uses:

1
Offering options: 〜なり〜なり. It gives two examples of the same kind of thing someone could do, followed by a request or a suggestion, or by what the speaker wants to do. With nouns, なり can come after a particle such as に or で.
  • 着なくなった服は、売るなり、友達にあげるなりしたらどう? Why not sell the clothes you don't wear any more, or give them to a friend?
  • 届いた荷物は、玄関になり台所になり、置いておいて。 When packages arrive, just leave them by the front door or in the kitchen.
2
Whichever it is: 〜であれ〜であれ. Two nouns of the same kind stand for the whole group, and what follows holds for all of them. 〜であろうと〜であろうと means the same.
  • 社員であれアルバイトであれ、店に出るときはこのエプロンをつけること。 Whether you're on the staff or part-time, you must wear this apron when working in the shop.
  • 手紙であろうとメールであろうと、お礼はその日のうちに書くことにしている。 Whether it's a letter or an email, I always write my thank-you note the same day.
3
Even if it is, whoever it is: 〜であれ. On its own, であれ (or であろうと) grants a point: 'even if it is'. It often has たとえ or どんな in front. After a question word such as 誰(だれ) or 何(なに), it means 'whoever it is' or 'whatever it is'. What follows is often the speaker's judgment or decision.
  • たとえ一日であれ、店を休むならお客さんに知らせるべきだ。 Even if it's only for a day, you should let your customers know if you're closing the shop.
  • 誰であれ、ここから先は靴を脱いでください。 Whoever you are, please take your shoes off from this point on.
Two set expressions:
  • 〜はどうであれ, 'whatever … may be': 味(あじ)はどうであれ、娘(むすめ)が初(はじ)めて作(つく)ってくれた料理(りょうり)だから、全部(ぜんぶ)食(た)べた, 'whatever it tasted like, it was the first meal my daughter had cooked for me, so I ate it all';
  • いずれにしても (also いずれにせよ, いずれにしろ), 'in any case', 'either way': 行(い)くか行(い)かないか、いずれにしても金曜日(きんようび)までに返事(へんじ)をください, 'whether you're coming or not, please reply by Friday either way'.
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.
Later on:
  • With a verb, 'no matter…' takes 〜(よ)うと (Lesson 8); after a noun, that form is であろうと, with the same meaning as here.
  • You'll meet two more uses of なり: なりに, 'in one's own way', in Lesson 11, and なりとも, 'at least', in Lesson 12.

How it attaches

  • Verb, なり〜なりdictionary formなり, twice,する休むなり帰るなりする
  • Noun, なり〜なり〜 (+ particle, not を or が)なり, twice水なりお茶なり
  • Noun, であれ〜であれ or であろうと, once or twice肉であれ魚であれ
  • な-adjective, であれ〜であれ, once or twice便利であれ不便であれ
  • Question word誰(だれ), 何(なん), どんなnounであれ何であれ

Pay attention to

  • なり〜なり: not for the past. It suggests what to do, so a sentence in the past doesn't follow it. To list things someone did, use 〜たり〜たり, which なり〜なり looks like:×休(やす)みの日(ひ)は草(くさ)を取(と)るなり車(くるま)を洗(あら)うなりした ○休(やす)みの日(ひ)は草(くさ)を取(と)ったり車(くるま)を洗(あら)ったりした
  • であれ: not after a verb. であれ follows a noun or a な-adjective. With a verb, the pair to use is 〜にしろ〜にしろ, which takes verbs too; putting であれ there gives a wrong form:×行(い)くであれ行(い)かないであれ ○行(い)くにしろ行(い)かないにしろ

Minimal pairs

  • 現金であれカードであれ、料金は入口の機械で払ってください。

    Whether by cash or card, please pay at the machine by the entrance. (であれ)

    現金にしろカードにしろ、料金は入口の機械で払ってください。

    Whether by cash or card, please pay at the machine by the entrance. (にしろ)

    The meaning is the same. であれ is formal and belongs to writing, which suits a notice like this.

Don't confuse with

  • Whether… or…, and even if: 〜にしろ〜にしろ, 〜にせよ, 〜にしても〜にしてもN2

    After a noun the two pairs are very close, and であれ is the more formal one: 平日(へいじつ)であれ日曜日(にちようび)であれ、この店(みせ)は九時(くじ)に開(ひら)く. にしろ also follows verbs: 歩(ある)くにしろバスに乗(の)るにしろ、駅(えき)までは三十分(さんじゅっぷん)かかる.

  • This and that, all mixed up: 〜やら〜やらN2

    やら〜やら (N2) names a few of the many things going on: 結婚(けっこん)の準備(じゅんび)やら新(あたら)しい仕事(しごと)やらで、今月(こんげつ)は忙(いそが)しい. なり〜なり names a few things someone could do: 週末(しゅうまつ)は、映画(えいが)なり買(か)い物(もの)なり、外(そと)に出(で)かけたら?

Report a mistake