← Library

〜たところで・〜にしたところで・〜ば〜でEven if you do, it won't help: 〜たところで, 〜にしたところで, 〜ば〜で

N1Concession and contrastLesson 8 · No going back, no matter what, it won't help

The た form + ところで says that even if you did something, it wouldn't help, or would make very little difference.

傘(かさ)をさしたところで、この風(かぜ)ではすぐに濡(ぬ)れてしまう。 Even with an umbrella up, you'd get soaked in no time in this wind.新(あたら)しいスマホにしたところで、電池(でんち)は一日(いちにち)しかもたない。 Even if you switched to a new smartphone, the battery would only last a day.

たところで supposes an action, or a state, that hasn't happened yet, and judges that it wouldn't be worth it. The verdict comes in the second part, so that part is negative: it won't help, it's too late, or the gain is small.

Uses:

1
It would make no difference: 〜たところで. The first part often has いくら, どんなに or 今(いま)さら in front. The second part is a negative verdict: not a wish, a plan or a request, and not a past event.
  • この古いパソコンにいくらお金をかけたところで、速くはならないよ。 However much money you spend on this old computer, it won't get any faster.
  • 私一人が反対したところで、会議の結論は変わらない。 Even if I objected on my own, it wouldn't change what the meeting decided.
  • そんな昔のことを今さら言ったところで、誰も覚えていないよ。 Even if you bring up something that old now, nobody will remember it.
2
No exception: 〜にしたところで, 〜としたところで. After a noun, it means 'even' or 'too': the person or thing named is in the same position as the rest. It often comes after a が meaning 'but', or after しかし. You can also use としたところで, or the less formal にしたって.
  • 村の人にしたところで、冬はこの山の奥までは入らない。 Even the people from the village don't go this far into the mountains in winter.
  • 生徒は試験が嫌いだが、先生にしたところで、試験を作るのは楽ではない。 Students hate exams, but teachers don't find writing them easy either.
3
Not as good, or as bad, as you'd think: 〜ば〜で, 〜なら〜で, 〜たら〜たで. The same word comes twice. If the case comes true, it brings its own problems; said of something unwelcome, it means it's no problem: 失敗(しっぱい)したら失敗(しっぱい)したで、また考(かんが)えればいい, 'if it fails, so be it, we'll think again'.
  • 雪が降らないとスキー場は困るが、降れば降ったで、道が凍って危ない。 The ski resort suffers when it doesn't snow, but when it does, the roads freeze and get dangerous.
  • 店は、有名なら有名で、いつも人が多くて入りにくい。 A famous restaurant has its own drawback, since it's always crowded and hard to get into.
  • 犬を飼ったら飼ったで、毎日散歩に連れていかなければならない。 Get a dog, and then you have to take it for a walk every day.
〜てもどうにもならない is a set way of saying 'it's no use …ing, nothing can be done about it':
  • ここで怒(おこ)ってもどうにもならない。冷静(れいせい)に話(はな)そう。 Getting angry here won't help. Let's talk about it calmly.
For 'it's no use' there is also 〜てもしかたがない (N3), and for 'even supposing', 〜としても (N3).
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.

How it attaches

  • Verb, 'even if'た formところで頼んだところで
  • Noun, 'even for…'nounにしたところで / としたところで社長にしたところで
  • Verb, with ば〜ばthe same verb in the た formで行けば行ったで
  • Verb, with たら〜たらthe same verb in the た formで言ったら言ったで
  • い-adjective〜いければthe same adjectiveで, or 〜いかったら〜いかったで安ければ安いで
  • な-adjective and noun〜ならthe same wordで静かなら静かで

Pay attention to

  • A request or permission: ても, not たところで. たところで can always be replaced by ても, but not the other way round. What follows たところで is a negative verdict, so a request or a question asking permission doesn't fit:×写真(しゃしん)を撮(と)ったところでいいですか ○写真(しゃしん)を撮(と)ってもいいですか
  • ところで at the start of a sentence. On its own at the start, ところで means 'by the way' and changes the subject: ところで、来週(らいしゅう)の予定(よてい)は? It has nothing to do with the た form.

Don't confuse with

  • How it turned out: 〜たところN2

    たところ reports what someone found out after doing something, and the second part is in the past: 祖母(そぼ)に聞(き)いたところ、この家(いえ)は百年前(ひゃくねんまえ)に建(た)てられたと分(わ)かった. たところで supposes the action and judges it useless: 祖母(そぼ)に聞(き)いたところで、いつ建(た)てられたかは分(わ)からないだろう.

  • Even if: 〜てもN4

    ても also works for something that really happened: 何度(なんど)計算(けいさん)しても、答(こた)えが合(あ)わなかった. たところで only supposes, and judges the action pointless: 何度(なんど)計算(けいさん)したところで、答(こた)えは合(あ)わないだろう.

  • From the standpoint of: 〜にしたら, 〜からすると, 〜上N2

    にしたら gives someone's point of view: 子供(こども)にしたら、この漢字(かんじ)の量(りょう)は大変(たいへん)だろう. にしたところで means that even they are no exception: 大人(おとな)にしたところで、この漢字(かんじ)の量(りょう)は大変(たいへん)だ.

Report a mistake