← Library

〜ものの・〜ことは〜がTrue, but…: 〜ものの, 〜ことは〜が

N2Concession and contrastLesson 10 · Although, not unless, because

Plain form + ものの admits a fact but says the expected result doesn't follow; 〜ことは〜が grants a point before 'but'.

高(たか)いレストランに行(い)ったものの、味(あじ)は普通(ふつう)だった。 We went to an expensive restaurant, but the food was nothing special.この道(みち)は近(ちか)いことは近(ちか)いが、夜(よる)は暗(くら)くて怖(こわ)い。 This way is quicker, I'll give it that, but it's dark and scary at night.

ものの admits that the first part is true, then says that what you would expect from it doesn't follow. The first part is a fact, or something almost certain; for 'even if', about something that may not happen, use 〜ても. Like 〜ながらも, ものの belongs to written Japanese.

Uses:

1
A fact with an unexpected outcome: 〜ものの. The first part is something that has happened or is true; the second says that what you'd expect from it doesn't follow, or that a problem remains. It often carries the speaker's regret or disappointment.
  • 嵐は夜のうちに去ったものの、朝になっても停電が続いている。 The storm passed in the night, but the power is still off this morning.
  • この公園は広いものの、座る場所がほとんどない。 This park is big, but there's hardly anywhere to sit.
  • 昨日は日曜日だったものの、店はすいていた。 Yesterday was a Sunday, but the shop was quiet.
2
Granting a point, but…: 〜ことは〜が. The word in front of ことは is repeated straight after it; then comes the 'but', with が or, in conversation, けど.
  • 田中さんに話した? 話したことは話したけど、ちゃんと聞いていなかったみたい。 Did you tell Mr. Tanaka? I told him, all right, but he didn't seem to be listening.
  • このコートは暖かいことは暖かいが、重くて肩が疲れる。 This coat is warm, I'll give it that, but it's heavy and makes my shoulders ache.
  • 新しい先生は親切なことは親切だが、説明が速すぎる。 The new teacher is certainly kind, but explains things far too fast.
With ことは〜が the speaker first grants that something is true, then puts the weight on what comes after が. In conversation, が can become けど.
〜とはいいながら, after a noun or the plain form, works the same way: 休(やす)みとはいいながら、朝(あさ)から仕事(しごと)の電話(でんわ)がかかってくる, 'it's meant to be my day off, yet I've been getting work calls since early this morning'.
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.
Later on:

How it attaches

  • Verbplain formものの着いたものの
  • い-adjective〜いものの古いものの
  • な-adjective〜な / 〜であるものの簡単なものの
  • Nounnounである / だったものの日曜日であるものの
  • Verb (ことは〜が)plain formことはthe same verbが書いたことは書いたが
  • い-adjective (ことは〜が)〜いことは〜いが広いことは広いが
  • な-adjective (ことは〜が)〜なことは〜だがきれいなことはきれいだが

Pay attention to

  • After ものの: no request or suggestion. The second part describes how things are or turned out. English 'although' can lead into a suggestion ('although the snow has stopped, let's not take the car'), but ものの can't:×雪(ゆき)はやんだものの、車(くるま)で出(で)かけるのはやめましょう ○雪(ゆき)はやんだけど、車(くるま)で出(で)かけるのはやめましょう
  • Talking to a friend: けど. ものの belongs to written Japanese; chatting with a friend, you'd use けど: 友達(ともだち)に聞(き)いたけど、誰(だれ)も知(し)らなかった.
  • Playing something down: といっても. To play down what you've just said, use といっても, from the same family as というより: 休(やす)みを取(と)ったといっても、二日(ふつか)だけです. ものの leaves the fact as it is and says that what you'd expect from it didn't happen: 休(やす)みを取(と)ったものの、ずっと家(いえ)で仕事(しごと)をしていた.

Minimal pairs

  • このパンはおいしいが、少し固い。

    This bread is good, but a bit hard.

    このパンはおいしいことはおいしいが、少し固い。

    This bread is good, I'll grant you, but it's a bit hard.

    In b the speaker first grants that the bread is good, then puts the weight on what follows: it's a bit hard.

Don't confuse with

  • Although: 〜ながらもN3

    After a verb, ながらも takes the ます stem, and both parts are about the same person: 兄(あに)は試験(しけん)に落(お)ちたと知(し)りながらも、明(あか)るく笑(わら)っていた. With ものの the second part can turn to something else: 会場(かいじょう)は広(ひろ)いものの、駅(えき)からの道(みち)が分(わ)かりにくい.

  • Even though, as a criticism: 〜くせにN3

    くせに criticizes someone else, with contempt or anger, and isn't used about the speaker. ものの criticizes no one and works for your own situation too: 傘(かさ)を持(も)って出(で)たものの、一日中(いちにちじゅう)雨(あめ)は降(ふ)らなかった.

Report a mistake