← Library

〜かと思(おも)ったら・〜か〜ないかのうちに・〜かと思(おも)ったNo sooner… than…: 〜かと思ったら, 〜か〜ないかのうちに, 〜かと思った

N2Time, sequence and durationLesson 1 · The right moment: on the occasion of, no sooner than, in the process of

The た form + かと思(おも)ったら or かと思(おも)うと describes two events in quick succession, the second a bit unexpected.

バスが来(き)たかと思(おも)ったら、そのまま通(とお)り過(す)ぎていった。 The bus had only just come along when it drove straight past without stopping.信号(しんごう)が青(あお)になるかならないかのうちに、隣(となり)の車(くるま)が走(はし)り出(だ)した。 The lights had barely turned green when the car next to us pulled away.新(あたら)しいかと思(おも)ったら、中古(ちゅうこ)のパソコンだった。 I thought the computer was new, but it was used.

かと思(おも)ったら describes two events the speaker observes: the first has just happened when the second follows, a little unexpectedly. It isn't used for the speaker's own actions. かと思(おも)うと works the same way, and you can drop か: 着(つ)いたと思(おも)ったら.

Uses:

1
One event straight after another. The first event has only just happened when another follows, taking the speaker a little by surprise.
  • 車のドアが開いたかと思ったら、大きな犬が飛び出してきた。 The car door had only just opened when a big dog leaped out.
  • その歌手は人気が出たかと思ったら、すぐに忘れられてしまった。 That singer had only just become popular when she was quickly forgotten.
  • 娘は宿題を始めたかと思うと、もう友達に電話している。 My daughter has only just started her homework, and she's already on the phone to a friend.
2
Almost at the same moment. The second event happens almost at the same moment as the first, leaving an even shorter gap than with かと思(おも)ったら. Use a verb for something that happens in an instant, such as 着(つ)く or 終(お)わる. You can't follow it with an intention or a request.
  • 料理がテーブルに置かれるか置かれないかのうちに、息子はもう食べ始めていた。 The food had barely been put on the table, and my son had already started eating.
  • 飛行機が止まるか止まらないかのうちに、何人かの客が席を立った。 The plane had hardly come to a stop when several passengers got out of their seats.
3
A first impression that turns out wrong. Here, かと思(おも)った expresses the speaker's own thought: for a moment, they believed something that wasn't true. You can then explain how things really were, using かと思(おも)ったら or かと思(おも)ったが.
  • 手紙が届いたので、返事かと思ったら、広告だった。 A letter arrived, and I thought it was the reply, but it was an ad.
  • 値段を見て、ゼロが一つ多いかと思った。 When I saw the price, for a moment I thought there was one zero too many.
〜なり (N1), 'the instant…', is close in meaning.
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.
Later on:

How it attaches

  • Verb, 'no sooner'た formかと思(おも)ったら / かと思(おも)うと開いたかと思うと
  • Verb, 'barely'dictionary formかない formかのうちに止まるか止まらないかのうちに
  • Verb, 'barely' (past)た formかない formかのうちに着いたか着かないかのうちに
  • Verb, impressionplain formかと思(おも)った忘れたかと思った
  • い-adjective, impression〜いかと思(おも)った高いかと思った
  • な-adjective, impressionwithout だかと思(おも)った暇かと思った
  • Noun, impressionnounかと思(おも)った本物かと思った

Pay attention to

  • One form, two uses. To tell them apart, ask whether the first thing really happened. In 電気(でんき)がついたかと思(おも)ったら、また消(き)えた the light did come on: two events in a row. In 本人(ほんにん)かと思(おも)ったら、双子(ふたご)の弟(おとうと)だった it wasn't him: an impression that turned out wrong. After a noun (本人(ほんにん)かと), only the second reading is possible: 'no sooner' needs a verb in the た form.
  • Your own action: とたん. In English you can say 'No sooner had I sat down than the phone rang', but かと思(おも)ったら isn't used for what the speaker does, and とたん is:×私(わたし)が座(すわ)ったかと思(おも)ったら、電話(でんわ)が鳴(な)った ○座(すわ)ったとたん、電話(でんわ)が鳴(な)った
  • A plan or a request: 〜たらすぐ. English 'as soon as' can introduce a plan, but the second part of かと思(おも)ったら reports what happened, so a plan or a request takes 〜たらすぐ:×雨(あめ)がやんだかと思(おも)ったら、出(で)かけましょう ○雨(あめ)がやんだらすぐ、出(で)かけましょう

Minimal pairs

  • 試合が始まったかと思ったら、田中選手がもうゴールを決めていた。

    The match had only just started, and Tanaka had already scored.

    試合が始まるか始まらないかのうちに、田中選手がもうゴールを決めていた。

    The match had barely kicked off, and Tanaka had already scored.

    With かと思(おも)ったら the goal comes just after the start, and it's a surprise; with か〜ないかのうちに it comes almost at the same moment as the kickoff.

Don't confuse with

  • The very moment: 〜たとたん(に)N3

    とたん can also follow the speaker's own action: 箱(はこ)を開(あ)けたとたん、虫(むし)が出(で)てきた. かと思(おも)ったら describes two events the speaker watches, the second a little unexpected: 姉(あね)は箱(はこ)を開(あ)けたかと思(おも)ったら、すぐに閉(し)めた.

  • Saying what you think: 〜と思いますN5

    会議(かいぎ)はもう終(お)わったと思(おも)った states what you believed. 会議(かいぎ)はもう終(お)わったかと思(おも)った, with the question particle か, is only a guess ('I wondered if it was over'), which is why it suits an impression that turns out wrong.

Report a mistake