← Library

〜べきだOught to: 〜べきだ

N3Obligation, permission and prohibitionLesson 5 · Duties and advice: you ought to, there's no choice, not necessarily, no need

Use dictionary form + べきだ for what you believe is the right or proper thing to do.

子供(こども)の質問(しつもん)には、きちんと答(こた)えるべきだ。 Children's questions ought to be answered properly.あの時(とき)、本当(ほんとう)のことを言(い)うべきだった。 I should have told the truth back then.

べき expresses your judgment of what is right, based on morals, common sense, or the duties of a role. With なければならない, by contrast, a rule or the situation leaves no choice. べき is also stronger than advice with ほうがいい, which describes what would be better for someone.

Uses:

1
Saying what is right to do. Use this to judge what is right or proper, either for everyone, as a rule for life, or for one particular person. You can follow it with と思(おも)う: 〜べきだと思(おも)う.
  • 子供の前では、親は言葉に気をつけるべきだ。 Parents ought to watch their language in front of children.
  • 会議で決まったことは、休んだ人にも説明すべきです。 What was decided at the meeting ought to be explained to those who weren't there.
2
Saying what shouldn't be done: 〜べきではない. This expresses a firm judgment that an action is wrong. The polite form is べきではありません.
  • 疲れているときに、大事なことを決めるべきではない。 You shouldn't make important decisions when you're tired.
  • 夜遅くに、大きな音で音楽を聞くべきではありません。 You shouldn't play loud music late at night.
3
Regret or criticism: 〜べきだった. The past form べきだった means that the right thing wasn't done. About yourself, it expresses regret, 'I should have'; about someone else, it is a criticism.
  • レストランを予約しておくべきだった。どこもいっぱいだ。 I should have made a restaurant reservation. Everywhere's full.
  • 田中さんは、出かける前に天気予報を見るべきでした。 Mr. Tanaka ought to have checked the weather forecast before he went out.
べき can also go directly before a noun: 見(み)るべき映画(えいが), 'a movie you ought to see'.
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.
Later on: In Lesson 15, you'll use ものだ for a general rule about how people behave, without addressing anyone in particular.

How it attaches

  • Verbdictionary formべきだ帰るべきだ
  • Verb with するす(る)べきだ連絡すべきだ
  • な-adjective〜であるべきだ公平であるべきだ
  • Noun〜であるべきだ無料であるべきだ

Pay attention to

  • The negative: べきではない. Keep the verb before べき affirmative and put the negation after it. This mistake comes from ほうがいい, where the negative goes on the verb (言(い)わないほうがいい):×言(い)わないべきだ ○言(い)うべきではない
  • With someone of higher status. Don't use べき when you are younger than the listener or lower in status, such as with a boss, teacher, or customer, even with です.
  • What you should do yourself. For what you yourself should do, Japanese usually uses なければならない rather than べき: 毎日(まいにち)運動(うんどう)しなければならない. For regret, however, you can use べきだった about yourself: 昨日(きのう)は早(はや)く寝(ね)るべきだった.

Minimal pairs

  • お店は、お客さんの意見をもっと聞くべきだ。

    Stores ought to listen more to what their customers think.

    お店は、お客さんの意見をもっと聞いたほうがいい。

    Stores would do well to listen more to what their customers think.

    With べきだ, the speaker judges it to be the right thing to do. With ほうがいい, it would be better, perhaps for the store's own benefit.

Don't confuse with

  • Advice: 〜ほうがいいN4

    ほうがいい advises what would be better: 寒(さむ)いからコートを着(き)たほうがいい. べき judges what is right: 人(ひと)の話(はなし)は最後(さいご)まで聞(き)くべきだ.

  • Obligation: 〜なければならないN4

    なければならない expresses an obligation, often imposed by a rule or a schedule: 八時(はちじ)までに出(で)なければならない. べき expresses the speaker's own judgment: 父(ちち)はもっと家族(かぞく)と話(はな)すべきだ.

  • Should be: 〜はずですN4

    はず expresses an expectation: 田中(たなか)さんはもう着(つ)いているはずだ, 'Tanaka should be there by now'. べき expresses what is right: 田中(たなか)さんは謝(あやま)るべきだ, 'Tanaka ought to apologize'. English uses 'should' for both.

Report a mistake