← Library

〜を問(と)わず・〜にかかわらず・〜もかまわずRegardless of: 〜を問わず, 〜にかかわらず, 〜もかまわず

N2Concession and contrastLesson 8 · Regardless, depending on, it's not that simple

Noun + を問(と)わず or にかかわらず says a difference doesn't matter; もかまわず describes acting without concern.

国籍(こくせき)を問(と)わず whatever their nationality買(か)う買(か)わないにかかわらず whether you buy or not服(ふく)が汚(よご)れるのもかまわず not caring if their clothes got dirty

を問(と)わず is built on 問(と)う, 'to ask' or 'to question', with the negative ず of written Japanese, so it means 'without asking about'. にかかわらず means the same, and the two can replace each other. Both go after a noun that covers a range of cases, after a pair of opposites, after a verb in its affirmative and negative forms or after かどうか, and both belong to written Japanese: notices, rules, job ads.

Uses:

1
Whatever the case: 〜を問わず. After a noun that covers a range of cases, such as 季節(きせつ) or 年齢(ねんれい), or after a pair of opposites such as 男女(だんじょ), it says that every case is included. The second half can repeat the idea with a question word and でも, such as 何(なに)でも or 誰(だれ)でも.
  • 祖母は、日本の料理、外国の料理を問わず、何でも上手に作る。 My grandmother can cook anything well, Japanese or foreign.
  • この町の祭りでは、年齢を問わず、みんなが同じ浴衣を着て踊る。 At this town's festival, everyone dances in the same yukata, whatever their age.
2
The same meaning: 〜にかかわらず, 〜にかかわりなく. にかかわらず means the same as を問(と)わず and goes after the same words, as in the examples here: a verb in its two forms, 聞(き)く聞(き)かない, or a question with かどうか. It is also written に関(かか)わらず, and にかかわりなく means the same.
  • 眼鏡をかけているかどうかにかかわらず、運転免許の試験では目の検査がある。 Whether or not you wear glasses, the driver's license test includes an eye exam.
  • 子供たちが聞く聞かないにかかわらず、祖父は毎晩昔の話をする。 Whether the children are listening or not, Grandpa tells stories about the old days every evening.
  • この会社では、年齢にかかわりなく、自由に意見が言える。 At this company, you can say what you think freely, whatever your age.
3
Not minding: 〜もかまわず. もかまわず describes someone who carries on without minding something people usually pay attention to: the people around them, the hour, their clothes. What follows is behavior that is unusual or surprising. After a verb or an adjective it needs の: 寝(ね)ているのもかまわず.
  • うちの猫は、私がパソコンを使っているのもかまわず、キーボードの上で寝る。 My cat goes to sleep on the keyboard, not caring that I'm using the computer.
  • 弟は雨もかまわず、傘も持たずに走って出ていった。 Without worrying about the rain, my younger brother ran out without even an umbrella.
もかまわず comes from かまう, 'to mind'. It describes a person who carries on without minding something people usually pay attention to.
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.

How it attaches

  • Nounnounを問(と)わず / にかかわらず曜日を問わず
  • Two opposite nounstwo nounsを問(と)わず / にかかわらず大人、子供を問わず
  • Verb, in both formsdictionary formない formを問(と)わず / にかかわらず乗る乗らないにかかわらず
  • A question〜かどうかを問(と)わず / にかかわらず来るかどうかにかかわらず
  • Noun (with もかまわず)nounもかまわず時間もかまわず
  • Verb, い-adjective (with もかまわず)plain formのもかまわず濡れるのもかまわず
  • な-adjective, noun (with もかまわず)〜な / 〜であるのもかまわず休みなのもかまわず

Pay attention to

  • にかかわらず or にもかかわらず. The two differ by one も, and look alike. にかかわらず says that a difference doesn't matter; にもかかわらず, 'despite', follows a fact. A pair such as 買(か)う買(か)わない isn't a fact, so it can't take にもかかわらず:×買(か)う買(か)わないにもかかわらず ○買(か)う買(か)わないにかかわらず
  • A rule for everyone: を問(と)わず. English 'regardless of' covers both a rule and a person's careless behavior, but もかまわず only describes what someone does without minding something; a rule or a service for everyone takes を問(と)わず or にかかわらず:×天気(てんき)もかまわず、このバスは時間(じかん)どおりに走(はし)ります ○天気(てんき)を問(と)わず、このバスは時間(じかん)どおりに走(はし)ります
  • After もかまわず: what someone does. What follows is an action, not a wish, an intention or a request. In English you can say 'call me, whatever the time'; in Japanese that request takes いつでも:×時間(じかん)もかまわず電話(でんわ)してください ○いつでも電話(でんわ)してください

Minimal pairs

  • 荷物を預ける預けないを問わず、出発の二時間前には空港に着いてください。

    Whether or not you're checking a bag, please be at the airport two hours before departure.

    荷物を預ける預けないにかかわらず、出発の二時間前には空港に着いてください。

    Whether or not you're checking a bag, please be at the airport two hours before departure.

    They mean the same. を問(と)わず, like にかかわらず, also goes after a verb in its two forms.

Don't confuse with

  • Despite: 〜にもかかわらず, 〜反面N2

    One も apart, and a different meaning. 試験(しけん)の結果(けっか)にかかわらず、来年(らいねん)もこの学校(がっこう)で勉強(べんきょう)を続(つづ)けるつもりだ: whatever the results turn out to be, the plan stays the same. 試験(しけん)に落(お)ちたにもかかわらず、兄(あに)は笑顔(えがお)だった: he really did fail, and he was smiling all the same.

  • Of all times, only for, and not only: 〜に限って, 〜に限り, 〜に限らずN2

    に限(かぎ)らず starts from one group and widens it: 平日(へいじつ)に限(かぎ)らず、週末(しゅうまつ)も練習(れんしゅう)がある, 'there's practice not just on weekdays but on weekends too'. を問(と)わず says the whole range makes no difference: 曜日(ようび)を問(と)わず練習(れんしゅう)がある, 'there's practice whatever the day'.

Report a mistake