← Library

〜たらどうMaking suggestions: 〜たらどう

N4Requests, questions and interactionLesson 8 · 'If' and 'when', and making suggestions

Make a suggestion with た form + らどうですか ('why don't you…?'); among friends, use たらどう? or just たら?

傘(かさ)を持(も)って行(い)ったらどうですか。 Why don't you take an umbrella?自分(じぶん)で作(つく)ってみたら? Why not try making it yourself?

The たら is the one in たら: literally, 'if you do it, how would that be?'. The speaker offers an idea, and the listener decides. To be more polite, 〜たらどうでしょうか or 〜たらいかがですか is used.

Uses:

1
Giving advice: 〜たらどうですか. The speaker suggests something the listener could do, for example about a problem they have just mentioned.
  • 最近(さいきん)、よく眠(ねむ)れないんです。 寝(ね)る前(まえ)に、少(すこ)し散歩(さんぽ)したらどうですか。 I haven't been sleeping well lately. Why don't you go for a short walk before bed?
  • この服(ふく)、ちょっと大(おお)きいんです。 じゃあ、店(みせ)の人(ひと)に聞(き)いてみたらどうですか。 These clothes are a bit big for me. Then why don't you try asking the store clerk?
2
Among friends: 〜たらどう?, 〜たら?. In speech the ending gets shorter: たらどう? or just たら?, with rising intonation.
  • おなか、すいたなあ。 冷蔵庫(れいぞうこ)のパン、食(た)べたら? I'm starving… Why not have the bread in the fridge?
  • 今(いま)の部屋(へや)、狭(せま)いんだ。 もっと広(ひろ)い部屋(へや)を探(さが)したらどう? My room's too small. Why don't you look for a bigger one?
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.
Later on: You'll learn to ask for advice rather than give it with 〜たらいいですか (N4 Lesson 13).

How it attaches

  • Verbた formらどうですか休(やす)んだらどうですか
  • More politeた formらいかがですか休(やす)んだらいかがですか
  • Among friendsた formらどう休(やす)んだらどう
  • Among friends, shorterた formら休(やす)んだら

Pay attention to

  • Invitations: ませんか. 〜たらどうですか suggests something for the listener to do; to invite someone to do something together, 〜ませんか is used:×今晩(こんばん)、私(わたし)たちと晩(ばん)ご飯(はん)を食(た)べたらどうですか ○今晩(こんばん)、私(わたし)たちと晩(ばん)ご飯(はん)を食(た)べませんか
  • When nobody has asked for advice. 〜たらどうですか can sound like a criticism, 'why haven't you done it already?': it is best kept for when the other person asks for advice.

Minimal pairs

  • 病院(びょういん)に行(い)ったらどう?

    How about going to the doctor's?

    病院(びょういん)に行(い)ったほうがいいよ。

    You'd better go to the doctor's.

    たらどう merely offers an idea; ほうがいい is firmer advice, close to an order.

Don't confuse with

  • Asking what to do: 〜たらいいですか, 〜ばいいですかN4

    どうしたらいいですか asks for advice; 早(はや)く寝(ね)たらどうですか gives it. The たら is the same: with いいですか you ask, with どうですか you suggest.

  • If, when: 〜たらN4

    雨(あめ)が降(ふ)ったら、出(で)かけません is a condition; 電話(でんわ)してみたら? is a suggestion. The たら is the same: what turns it into a suggestion is どう(ですか) at the end, or just rising intonation.

Report a mistake