← Library

〜ともなく・〜ながらにWithout meaning to; as it always was: 〜ともなく, 〜ながらに

N1Emphasis and nuanceLesson 5 · How people behave: as if to say, without meaning to, bad habits, taking advantage

Verb + ともなく means 'idly'; question word + ともなく leaves who or where unclear; ながらに describes states in set phrases.

母(はは)は台所(だいどころ)で、子供(こども)たちの話(はなし)を聞(き)くともなく聞(き)いていた。 In the kitchen, Mom was half-listening to the children talking.この喫茶店(きっさてん)は、昔(むかし)ながらの味(あじ)を守(まも)っている。 This café has kept the taste it has always had.

The two forms aren't related in meaning; they share this card because they're learned at the same stage. ともなく describes an action done with little intention, or something whose source nobody can pin down. ながらに describes a state that has stayed as it was, and goes with only a few words, best learned one by one.

Uses:

1
Doing something idly: verb + ともなく. After the dictionary form of a few verbs such as 見(み)る, 聞(き)く or 待(ま)つ, ともなく describes doing something without really meaning to: the eyes or ears are on it, the mind is elsewhere. The same verb often follows straight after: 聞(き)くともなく聞(き)く. ともなしに means the same.
  • 病院の待合室で、壁のポスターを読むともなく読んでいた。 In the hospital waiting room, I was idly reading the posters on the wall.
  • 公園のベンチで、池の鳥を眺めるともなく眺めていた。 On a park bench, I sat idly watching the birds on the pond.
2
Nobody knows where or who: question word + ともなく. After a question word, with or without a particle such as から or へ, it means that nobody can tell who, where or when: どこからともなく, 'from who knows where'; どこへともなく, 'off to who knows where', for something going away; 誰(だれ)からともなく, 'with no one in particular starting it'.
  • 演奏が終わると、その男はどこへともなく姿を消した。 When the music ended, the man disappeared, off to who knows where.
  • みんな黙ってしまったが、誰からともなく笑い出した。 Everyone had gone quiet, but then, with no one in particular starting it, they all burst out laughing.
3
Set phrases for a state: 〜ながらに, 〜ながらの. ながらに, before a verb, and ながらの, before a noun, describe a state that has stayed as it was. They go with only a few words, in set phrases: 生(う)まれながらに, 'from birth'; 昔(むかし)ながらの, 'as it has always been'; いながらにして, 'without leaving where you are'. 涙(なみだ)ながらに, 'in tears', is an idiom: it means 泣(な)きながら.
  • 祖父は、生まれながらの漁師だ。 My grandfather is a born fisherman.
  • 引退する選手は、涙ながらに、応援してくれた人たちにお礼を言った。 In tears, the retiring player thanked everyone who had supported her.
Watch out: what to use depends on the context; see Pay attention to below.

How it attaches

  • Verb, ともなくdictionary formともなく (+ the same verb)見るともなく見る
  • Question word〜 (+ particle)ともなくどこからともなく
  • Verb, ながらにます stemながら(に), ながらのnoun生まれながらに
  • Noun, ながらに〜ながら(に), ながらのnoun昔ながらの

Pay attention to

  • 生(う)まれながらに isn't 'while being born'. The ながら of 〜ながら (N4) links two actions done at the same time; 生(う)まれながらに means 'from birth': there is no second action, just a state that hasn't changed since.
  • どことなく, a different word. どことなく, with と and no も, means 'somehow, vaguely': どことなく寂(さび)しい, 'somehow sad'. どこからともなく is 'from who knows where'.

Minimal pairs

  • 店の前で、看板を見ていた。

    I was looking at the sign outside the shop.

    店の前で、看板を見るともなく見ていた。

    I was looking at the sign outside the shop without really taking it in.

    見(み)ていた only states what you were looking at. 見(み)るともなく見(み)ていた adds that you had no reason to: your eyes were on the sign, your mind elsewhere.

Don't confuse with

  • Doing two things at once: 〜ながらN4

    音楽(おんがく)を聞(き)きながら掃除(そうじ)する: two actions at once, listening and cleaning. 外(そと)の雨(あめ)の音(おと)を聞(き)くともなく聞(き)く: a single action, done without really meaning to.

Report a mistake